Demand Response
Grid programs that pay large electricity users to cut their usage when the grid is under strain. Bitcoin miners in Texas are among the companies paid to power down.
Demand response is the set of grid programs that pay large electricity users to cut their usage when the grid is stressed. In Texas, for example, the grid operator ERCOT strikes deals with flexible power buyers and pays them to cut back so the grid isn't overstressed when air conditioners are running flat out. The grid gets load it can shed at the worst moments; the customer gets paid for being flexible.
Bitcoin miners are among those buyers. Riot Platforms, a miner with sites in Texas, says in its annual report that mining load can be quickly curtailed, and that the payments offset the mining revenue it gives up while switched off. Even miners without a deal with the grid sometimes power down on their own when prices spike.
The Texas receipt
Riot's filings show how this plays out on ERCOT, the Texas grid. In August 2023, during a heat wave, Riot reported $31.7 million in credits for a single month: $24.2 million from selling power it had bought under long-term contracts back to the grid at spot prices, plus $7.4 million in demand-response credits. The 333 bitcoin it mined that month were worth about $8.9 million at the end of the month. During the periods of peak demand, Riot cut its power use by more than 95 percent.
Riot's annual report for 2023 describes three ways powering down pays off for it:
- Selling power back. Riot buys power at a fixed price under a long-term contract, so when spot prices spike it can stop mining and sell the unused power back to the grid.
- Ancillary services. Riot bids to sell ERCOT the right to switch off part of its load on command, and is paid whether or not ERCOT ever calls on it.
- Peak avoidance. ERCOT's Four Coincident Peak (4CP) program looks at the single highest-demand interval in each of four summer months, June through September. Riot powered down at those peaks in 2022, which substantially cut the transmission charges on its 2023 power bills.
The debate
Critics see these payments differently. In October 2022, eight members of Congress, including Senators Elizabeth Warren and Ed Markey, wrote to ERCOT calling its demand-response payments to miners subsidies that come at the expense of ratepayers, and said mining puts a strain on the grid. After Riot's August 2023 numbers came out, Luke Metzger, executive director of the group Environment Texas, called the $31.7 million absurd, said other Texans weren't paid for cutting their own use, and argued that ERCOT should pay households to conserve instead. A 2023 Texas bill, SB 1751, would have capped how much miners could take part in these programs. It passed the state Senate and died in a House committee.
Riot's side, in its filings, is that its curtailment helped lower total demand on the grid during the heat wave and helped keep consumers' power on, and that it bids against other market participants to sell these services to ERCOT.
See the Bitcoin and Energy rabbit hole for the full grid-services argument and the criticism of it.
Key takeaways
- Grid operators pay large users to cut their load when demand peaks
- Riot Platforms, a bitcoin miner, cut its power use by more than 95% at peak times in August 2023
- Riot got $31.7M in power and demand-response credits that month, more than the bitcoin it mined
Sources (5)
- Riot Platforms - August 2023 production and operations update, SEC Form 8-K exhibit 99.1 (September 6, 2023): $24.2 million in power credits from selling power back to ERCOT under its long-term power contracts and $7.4 million in demand response credits, both estimates; $31.7 million in total; 333 bitcoin produced; power use curtailed by more than 95% during peak demand, which Riot says reduced ERCOT demand and helped keep consumers' service uninterrupted; mining operations in central Texas
- Riot Platforms - Form 10-K for 2023: bitcoin mining can be quickly curtailed; demand response funds offset foregone operational revenue; mining at a low fixed energy cost under a long-term PPA; credits from sales of unused power under its PPA and from ERCOT ancillary services; ancillary services, bid competitively against other market participants, sell ERCOT the ability to power down part of Riot's load on demand and pay whether or not Riot is called; Four Coincident Peak (4CP) program, whose 2022 participation substantially reduced its 2023 transmission charges
- CNBC - Texas paid bitcoin miner Riot $31.7 million to shut down during heat wave in August: ERCOT strikes deals with flexible energy buyers like crypto miners, and its demand response programs pay miners to reduce power when air conditioners run at full blast; the 333 bitcoin mined were worth about $8.9 million at month end; miners without a deal sometimes power down when prices spike; SB 1751 passed the Texas Senate and stalled in a House committee (September 6, 2023)
- KVUE - Environmental group blasts ERCOT policy to pay cryptocurrency mining companies to stop operations: Environment Texas executive director Luke Metzger calls the $31.7 million absurd and says ERCOT should pay residential customers to conserve instead; SB 1751 would have capped the mining industry's participation in demand response programs but died in committee (September 7, 2023)
- Senator Ed Markey - Lawmakers open investigation into Texas energy grid operator's subsidies to cryptominers: letter from eight members of Congress calling ERCOT's demand response payments to miners subsidies that come at the expense of ratepayers, and saying mining strains the grid (October 12, 2022)
Related terms (5)
Published . Revised . No corrections logged for this page.
Edit this page on GitHub