CFP Bitcoin Scalability Workshop (Sept 12-13), Montreal Canada
3 messages, 11 to 14 Aug 2015. Started by Pindar Wong.
Pindar Wong (2), Mark F
Bitcoin Scalability Workshops
In recent months the Bitcoin development community has faced difficult discussions of how to safely improve the scalability and decentralized nature of the Bitcoin network. To aid the technical consensus building process we are organizing a pair of workshops to collect technical criteria, present proposals and evaluate technical materials and data with academic discipline and analysis that fully considers the complex tradeoffs between decentralization, utility, security and operational realities. This may be considered as similar in intent and process to the NIST-SHA3 design process where performance and security were in a tradeoff for a security critical application.
Since Bitcoin is a P2P currency with many stakeholders, it is important to collect requirements as broadly as possible, and through the process enhance everyone’s understanding of the technical properties of Bitcoin to help foster an inclusive, transparent, and informed process.
Those with technical interest are invited to participate in this pair of workshops with the following intent:
Phase 1: Scene setting, evaluation criteria, and tradeoff analysis.
Montreal, Canada: September 12th-13th, 2015
Scalability is not a single parameter; there are many opportunities to make the Bitcoin protocol more efficient and better able to service the needs of its growing userbase. Each approach to further scaling the Bitcoin blockchain involves implicit trade offs of desired properties of the whole system. As a community we need to raise awareness of the complex and subtle issues involved, facilitate deeper research and testing of existing proposals, and motivate future work in this area.
The purpose of this workshop is to discuss the general tradeoffs and requirements of any proposal to scale Bitcoin beyond its present limits. Session topics are to include the presentation of experimental data relating to known bottlenecks of Bitcoin’s continued growth and analysis of implicit tradeoffs involved in general strategies for enabling future growth.
This event will not host sessions on the topic of any specific proposals involving changes to the Bitcoin protocol. Such proposals would be the topic of a 2nd, follow-on Phase 2 workshop described below; this event is intended to “set the stage” for work on and evaluation of specific proposals in the time between the workshops.
Phase 2 will be planned out further as part of Phase 1 with input from the participants.
Phase 2: Presentation and review of technical proposals, with simulation, benchmark results.
Hong Kong, SAR, China: TBD Nov/Dec 2015
Hopefully to be easier for the Chinese miners to attend, the second workshop pertaining to actual block size proposals is to be planned for Hong Kong roughly in the late November to December timeframe.
The purpose of this workshop is to present and review actual proposals for scaling Bitcoin against the requirements gathered in Phase 1. Multiple competing proposals will be presented, with experimental data, and compared against each other. The goal is to raise awareness of scalability issues and build a pathway toward consensus for increasing Bitcoin’s transaction processing capacity or, barring that, identify key areas of further required research and next steps for moving forward.
Preliminarily, Phase 2 will be a time to share results from experiments performed as a result of Phase 1 and an opportunity to discuss new developments.
How do the Workshops work?
-
Both events will be live-streamed with remote participation facilitated via IRC for parallel online discussion and passing questions to the event. -
These workshops aim to facilitate the existing Bitcoin Improvement Proposals (BIP)[1] process. Most work will be done outside of the workshops in the intervening months. The workshops serve to be additive to the design and review process by raising awareness of diverse points of view, studies, simulations, and proposals. -
Travel, venue details, and accommodation recommendation are available at scalingbitcoin.org. Registration begins August 12th at an early-bird ticket price of $150 USD until September 3rd. The ticket prices do not come close to covering the venue expense and travel subsidies, hence the need for corporate sponsors. -
Please see the FAQ at scalingbitcoin.org which should answer most other questions.
Travel Subsidies for Independent/Academic Researchers
There will be an application process for independent or academic researchers to apply for travel assistance to help cover the expense of airfare and hotel fees up to $1,000 per qualified presenter who intends to give a presentation. The four underwriters of this event have agreed to jointly review applications and cover the travel subsidies for qualified presenters. See scalingbitcoin.org for details.
Sponsors of the Montreal Workshop
The first workshop is hosted and with logistics handled by the Montreal consultancy CryptoMechanics <http://cryptomechanics.com>.
The Underwriters jointly responsible for venue expenses and researcher travel subsidies are currently the MIT Digital Currency Initiative, Chaincode Labs, Blockstream, and Chain.com.
Current sponsors include: Cryptsy, BitcoinTalk, Final Hash, Blockstream, MIT DCI, Chaincode Labs, IDEO Futures, Kraken, and Chain.com.
Additional sponsors are needed. Please see scalingbitcoin.org for sponsorship details or contact me directly via < pindar dot wong at gmail.com >
Online Workshop Resources
-
Bitcoin-Workshops-Announce list
https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/bitcoin-workshops-announce -
Bitcoin-Workshops discussion list https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/bitcoin-workshops -
#bitcoin-workshops chat on the Freenode IRC network http://webchat.freenode.net/?channels=bitcoin-workshops
Call for Proposals/Papers/Presentations
If you have any research relevant to issues surrounding Bitcoin scalability, your proposal for a presentation at the Montreal workshop would be most welcome. Please see scalingbitcoin.org for submission details.
Pindar Wong
Chair, Montreal Workshop Planning Committee
Chairman, VeriFi (Hong Kong) Ltd.
[1] https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Bitcoin_Improvement_Proposals
I want to put a big thank-you out to Pindar, Warren, and others in the organizing committee who I know must have put in a lot of hours to make this happen. I will be attending, and I hope to see many of you there too. It is my sincere hope that the academic structure of a workshop will help break down some of the communication walls that have arisen in this debate, and help us all work towards finding a compromise towards scaling bitcoin, something we all want to see happen.
On Tue, Aug 11, 2015 at 1:45 AM, Pindar Wong via bitcoin-dev < bitcoin-dev@lists•linuxfoundation•org> wrote:
Quoted text (160 lines)
> Bitcoin Scalability Workshops > > In recent months the Bitcoin development community has faced difficult > discussions of how to safely improve the scalability and decentralized > nature of the Bitcoin network. To aid the technical consensus building > process we are organizing a pair of workshops to collect technical > criteria, present proposals and evaluate technical materials and data with > academic discipline and analysis that fully considers the complex tradeoffs > between decentralization, utility, security and operational realities. This > may be considered as similar in intent and process to the NIST-SHA3 design > process where performance and security were in a tradeoff for a security > critical application. > > Since Bitcoin is a P2P currency with many stakeholders, it is important to > collect requirements as broadly as possible, and through the process > enhance everyone’s understanding of the technical properties of Bitcoin to > help foster an inclusive, transparent, and informed process. > > Those with technical interest are invited to participate in this pair of > workshops with the following intent: > > Phase 1: Scene setting, evaluation criteria, and tradeoff analysis. > > Montreal, Canada: September 12th-13th, 2015 > > Scalability is not a single parameter; there are many opportunities to > make the Bitcoin protocol more efficient and better able to service the > needs of its growing userbase. Each approach to further scaling the Bitcoin > blockchain involves implicit trade offs of desired properties of the whole > system. As a community we need to raise awareness of the complex and subtle > issues involved, facilitate deeper research and testing of existing > proposals, and motivate future work in this area. > > The purpose of this workshop is to discuss the general tradeoffs and > requirements of any proposal to scale Bitcoin beyond its present limits. > Session topics are to include the presentation of experimental data > relating to known bottlenecks of Bitcoin’s continued growth and analysis of > implicit tradeoffs involved in general strategies for enabling future > growth. > > This event will not host sessions on the topic of any specific proposals > involving changes to the Bitcoin protocol. Such proposals would be the > topic of a 2nd, follow-on Phase 2 workshop described below; this event is > intended to “set the stage” for work on and evaluation of specific > proposals in the time between the workshops. > > Phase 2 will be planned out further as part of Phase 1 with input from the > participants. > > Phase 2: Presentation and review of technical proposals, with simulation, > benchmark results. > > Hong Kong, SAR, China: TBD Nov/Dec 2015 > > Hopefully to be easier for the Chinese miners to attend, the second > workshop pertaining to actual block size proposals is to be planned for > Hong Kong roughly in the late November to December timeframe. > > The purpose of this workshop is to present and review actual proposals for > scaling Bitcoin against the requirements gathered in Phase 1. Multiple > competing proposals will be presented, with experimental data, and compared > against each other. The goal is to raise awareness of scalability issues > and build a pathway toward consensus for increasing Bitcoin’s transaction > processing capacity or, barring that, identify key areas of further > required research and next steps for moving forward. > > Preliminarily, Phase 2 will be a time to share results from experiments > performed as a result of Phase 1 and an opportunity to discuss new > developments. > > How do the Workshops work? > > - > > Both events will be live-streamed with remote participation > facilitated via IRC for parallel online discussion and passing questions to > the event. > - > > These workshops aim to facilitate the existing Bitcoin Improvement > Proposals (BIP)[1] process. Most work will be done outside of the workshops > in the intervening months. The workshops serve to be additive to the design > and review process by raising awareness of diverse points of view, studies, > simulations, and proposals. > - > > Travel, venue details, and accommodation recommendation are available > at scalingbitcoin.org. Registration begins August 12th at an > early-bird ticket price of $150 USD until September 3rd. The ticket prices > do not come close to covering the venue expense and travel subsidies, hence > the need for corporate sponsors. > - > > Please see the FAQ at scalingbitcoin.org which should answer most > other questions. > > > Travel Subsidies for Independent/Academic Researchers > > There will be an application process for independent or academic > researchers to apply for travel assistance to help cover the expense of > airfare and hotel fees up to $1,000 per qualified presenter who intends to > give a presentation. The four underwriters of this event have agreed to > jointly review applications and cover the travel subsidies for qualified > presenters. See scalingbitcoin.org for details. > > Sponsors of the Montreal Workshop > > The first workshop is hosted and with logistics handled by the Montreal > consultancy CryptoMechanics <http://cryptomechanics.com>. > > The Underwriters jointly responsible for venue expenses and researcher > travel subsidies are currently the MIT Digital Currency Initiative, > Chaincode Labs, Blockstream, and Chain.com. > > Current sponsors include: Cryptsy, BitcoinTalk, Final Hash, Blockstream, > MIT DCI, Chaincode Labs, IDEO Futures, Kraken, and Chain.com. > > Additional sponsors are needed. Please see scalingbitcoin.org for > sponsorship details or contact me directly via < pindar dot wong at > gmail.com > > > Online Workshop Resources > > - > > Bitcoin-Workshops-Announce list > > https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/bitcoin-workshops-announce > - > > Bitcoin-Workshops discussion list > https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/bitcoin-workshops > - > > #bitcoin-workshops chat on the Freenode IRC network > http://webchat.freenode.net/?channels=bitcoin-workshops > > > Call for Proposals/Papers/Presentations > > If you have any research relevant to issues surrounding Bitcoin > scalability, your proposal for a presentation at the Montreal workshop > would be most welcome. Please see scalingbitcoin.org for submission > details. > > Pindar Wong > > Chair, Montreal Workshop Planning Committee > > Chairman, VeriFi (Hong Kong) Ltd. > > [1] https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Bitcoin_Improvement_Proposals > > _______________________________________________ > bitcoin-dev mailing list > bitcoin-dev@lists•linuxfoundation•org > https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/bitcoin-dev > >
Dear Mark,
Thank you for your email.
Registration <http://scalingbitcoin.brownpapertickets.com/> was opened on Wednesday as planned and we list some initial background papers here: https://scalingbitcoin.org/papers/
To encourage early submissions to help with planning, review and circulation, we will accept on a rolling basis, expressions of interest and proposals surrounding Bitcoin scalability *until 00.00 UTC Sept 1st 2015*.
Please email them to proposals@scalingbitcoin•org
I very much looking forward to meeting you and to the technical discussions in Montreal next month!
Please feel free to also follow us on Twitter @ScalingBitcoin
Yours sincerely,
Pindar Wong
Chair, Montreal Workshop Planning Committee
Chairman, VeriFi (Hong Kong) Ltd.
On Wed, Aug 12, 2015 at 3:13 AM, Mark Friedenbach <mark@friedenbach•org> wrote:
Quoted text (172 lines)
> I want to put a big thank-you out to Pindar, Warren, and others in the > organizing committee who I know must have put in a lot of hours to make > this happen. I will be attending, and I hope to see many of you there too. > It is my sincere hope that the academic structure of a workshop will help > break down some of the communication walls that have arisen in this debate, > and help us all work towards finding a compromise towards scaling bitcoin, > something we all want to see happen. > > On Tue, Aug 11, 2015 at 1:45 AM, Pindar Wong via bitcoin-dev < > bitcoin-dev@lists•linuxfoundation•org> wrote: > >> Bitcoin Scalability Workshops >> >> In recent months the Bitcoin development community has faced difficult >> discussions of how to safely improve the scalability and decentralized >> nature of the Bitcoin network. To aid the technical consensus building >> process we are organizing a pair of workshops to collect technical >> criteria, present proposals and evaluate technical materials and data with >> academic discipline and analysis that fully considers the complex tradeoffs >> between decentralization, utility, security and operational realities. This >> may be considered as similar in intent and process to the NIST-SHA3 design >> process where performance and security were in a tradeoff for a security >> critical application. >> >> Since Bitcoin is a P2P currency with many stakeholders, it is important >> to collect requirements as broadly as possible, and through the process >> enhance everyone’s understanding of the technical properties of Bitcoin to >> help foster an inclusive, transparent, and informed process. >> >> Those with technical interest are invited to participate in this pair of >> workshops with the following intent: >> >> Phase 1: Scene setting, evaluation criteria, and tradeoff analysis. >> >> Montreal, Canada: September 12th-13th, 2015 >> >> Scalability is not a single parameter; there are many opportunities to >> make the Bitcoin protocol more efficient and better able to service the >> needs of its growing userbase. Each approach to further scaling the Bitcoin >> blockchain involves implicit trade offs of desired properties of the whole >> system. As a community we need to raise awareness of the complex and subtle >> issues involved, facilitate deeper research and testing of existing >> proposals, and motivate future work in this area. >> >> The purpose of this workshop is to discuss the general tradeoffs and >> requirements of any proposal to scale Bitcoin beyond its present limits. >> Session topics are to include the presentation of experimental data >> relating to known bottlenecks of Bitcoin’s continued growth and analysis of >> implicit tradeoffs involved in general strategies for enabling future >> growth. >> >> This event will not host sessions on the topic of any specific proposals >> involving changes to the Bitcoin protocol. Such proposals would be the >> topic of a 2nd, follow-on Phase 2 workshop described below; this event is >> intended to “set the stage” for work on and evaluation of specific >> proposals in the time between the workshops. >> >> Phase 2 will be planned out further as part of Phase 1 with input from >> the participants. >> >> Phase 2: Presentation and review of technical proposals, with simulation, >> benchmark results. >> >> Hong Kong, SAR, China: TBD Nov/Dec 2015 >> >> Hopefully to be easier for the Chinese miners to attend, the second >> workshop pertaining to actual block size proposals is to be planned for >> Hong Kong roughly in the late November to December timeframe. >> >> The purpose of this workshop is to present and review actual proposals >> for scaling Bitcoin against the requirements gathered in Phase 1. Multiple >> competing proposals will be presented, with experimental data, and compared >> against each other. The goal is to raise awareness of scalability issues >> and build a pathway toward consensus for increasing Bitcoin’s transaction >> processing capacity or, barring that, identify key areas of further >> required research and next steps for moving forward. >> >> Preliminarily, Phase 2 will be a time to share results from experiments >> performed as a result of Phase 1 and an opportunity to discuss new >> developments. >> >> How do the Workshops work? >> >> - >> >> Both events will be live-streamed with remote participation >> facilitated via IRC for parallel online discussion and passing questions to >> the event. >> - >> >> These workshops aim to facilitate the existing Bitcoin Improvement >> Proposals (BIP)[1] process. Most work will be done outside of the workshops >> in the intervening months. The workshops serve to be additive to the design >> and review process by raising awareness of diverse points of view, studies, >> simulations, and proposals. >> - >> >> Travel, venue details, and accommodation recommendation are available >> at scalingbitcoin.org. Registration begins August 12th at an >> early-bird ticket price of $150 USD until September 3rd. The ticket prices >> do not come close to covering the venue expense and travel subsidies, hence >> the need for corporate sponsors. >> - >> >> Please see the FAQ at scalingbitcoin.org which should answer most >> other questions. >> >> >> Travel Subsidies for Independent/Academic Researchers >> >> There will be an application process for independent or academic >> researchers to apply for travel assistance to help cover the expense of >> airfare and hotel fees up to $1,000 per qualified presenter who intends to >> give a presentation. The four underwriters of this event have agreed to >> jointly review applications and cover the travel subsidies for qualified >> presenters. See scalingbitcoin.org for details. >> >> Sponsors of the Montreal Workshop >> >> The first workshop is hosted and with logistics handled by the Montreal >> consultancy CryptoMechanics <http://cryptomechanics.com>. >> >> The Underwriters jointly responsible for venue expenses and researcher >> travel subsidies are currently the MIT Digital Currency Initiative, >> Chaincode Labs, Blockstream, and Chain.com. >> >> Current sponsors include: Cryptsy, BitcoinTalk, Final Hash, Blockstream, >> MIT DCI, Chaincode Labs, IDEO Futures, Kraken, and Chain.com. >> >> Additional sponsors are needed. Please see scalingbitcoin.org for >> sponsorship details or contact me directly via < pindar dot wong at >> gmail.com > >> >> Online Workshop Resources >> >> - >> >> Bitcoin-Workshops-Announce list >> >> https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/bitcoin-workshops-announce >> - >> >> Bitcoin-Workshops discussion list >> https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/bitcoin-workshops >> - >> >> #bitcoin-workshops chat on the Freenode IRC network >> http://webchat.freenode.net/?channels=bitcoin-workshops >> >> >> Call for Proposals/Papers/Presentations >> >> If you have any research relevant to issues surrounding Bitcoin >> scalability, your proposal for a presentation at the Montreal workshop >> would be most welcome. Please see scalingbitcoin.org for submission >> details. >> >> Pindar Wong >> >> Chair, Montreal Workshop Planning Committee >> >> Chairman, VeriFi (Hong Kong) Ltd. >> >> [1] https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Bitcoin_Improvement_Proposals >> >> _______________________________________________ >> bitcoin-dev mailing list >> bitcoin-dev@lists•linuxfoundation•org >> https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/bitcoin-dev >> >> >